Good to know
- Poshmark. If your return address is in Texas, Poshmark adds tax on 80% of its seller fee, at the Texas rate for your location. That extra is not included here.
- Poshmark. Any shipping discount you offer, and label upgrades above 5 lb ($5 up to 10 lb, $10 up to 15 lb), come out of your earnings.
- Whatnot. Whatnot sometimes runs promotional rates, such as 0% fees for new sellers or limited-time category promotions, which replace your earned rate while they last. They are not included here, so results during a promotion may overstate your fees.
- Whatnot. In some states tax is deducted on Whatnot's fees, which is not included here. Whatnot lists the states on its fees pages.
How each one charges
A flat $2.95 under $15 and 20% from $15 up. The buyer pays for the label.
Commission from 8% for most sellers, on the item only, plus 2.9% + $0.30 for processing.
The same sale on both
Say you sell an item you paid $10.00 for at $50.00, with free shipping to the buyer, $8.00 for the label where you pay for it, and 7% sales tax. Poshmark takes $10.00 (Poshmark fee $10.00). Whatnot takes $5.85 (Commission (8%) $4.00, Payment processing $1.85). On both, the buyer normally pays for the label.
You keep $30.00 on Poshmark and $34.15 on Whatnot, so Whatnot comes out $4.15 ahead of Poshmark on this sale.
At other prices
At $15.00, Whatnot leaves you $1.03 more than Poshmark ($13.03 against $12.00 after fees and shipping). At $150.00, Whatnot leaves you $13.05 more than Poshmark ($133.05 against $120.00 after fees and shipping).
Whatnot leaves more at every whole-dollar price up to $500 with the same shipping and tax, so on fees alone the order does not change.
Fees are not the whole story
A lower fee only matters if the item sells. The buyers, the categories that move and the prices people pay all differ between marketplaces, and so do the fees buyers pay on top. Use the numbers to set your floor price on each, then list where the buyers are.
Many resellers list the same item on both and take it down from the other one as soon as it sells. Summit lists to Poshmark and Whatnot and, once it picks up a sale, takes the other listing down. Picking up the sale can lag, so check before you ship.
Common questions
Which has lower fees, Poshmark or Whatnot?
On fees, Whatnot leaves more at $15, $50 and $150, with the same shipping and 7% tax. Enter your own numbers above to check yours.
Who pays for shipping on Poshmark and Whatnot?
On both, the buyer normally pays for the label. Where you pay, offering free shipping comes straight out of what you keep, so it counts as much as the fee.
Can I sell the same item on Poshmark and Whatnot?
Yes, as long as you take it down from the other one as soon as it sells, so you never sell it twice. That is the part cross-listing tools exist to do.